48 / 66
Software Verification Examples for SCADA Pro
48
Table B2.2.1. Comparison of Results for Vertical Displacements (Comb1).
Vertical
Displacement (mm)
at
ScadaPro
Sofistik
Cedrus-5
center
point of plate
1.04
1.08
1.05
middle point of free
side
1.33
1.19
1.14
Table B2.2.2. Comparison of Results for Bending Moments (Comb2).
Bending Moment
ScadaPro
Sofistik
Cedrus-5
Myy (kNm/m) at
center of plate
35.00
34.94
35.03
Mxx (kNm/m) at
middle point of
free side
8.44
9.60
8.23
Table B2.2.3 Comparison of Results for Reinforcement (Comb2).
Reinforcement
ScadaPro
Sofistik
Cedrus-5
Xk (cm
2
/m) at
center of plate
3.97
3.44
3.91
Zk (cm
2
/m) at
middle point of
free side
1.95
1.56
1.64
Computer Files
The project file for this example is “B2_FIX”. These files are provided as part of the
ScadaPro installation.
Conclusion
The result comparison reflects acceptable agreement between ScadaPro software and results
obtained from Sofistik and Cedrus-5.